April Fool’s Day Menu: 15 Spectacular Fakeout Foods

04/01/2014 at 12:25 PM ET
1 of 16
Courtesy Pinterest Via Schax Yusuf

Sometimes faking it is a good thing. In honor of April Fool’s Day, we found scrumptious-looking foods that purport to be something they’re not — cakes that look like vegetables, and strawberry jam masquerading as cocktail sauce. Surprise your family with these fun, delicious recipes — and have the last laugh.

Courtesy Pinterest via diaryofamadhausfrau.com

All you need to make these pigs in a blanket are marzipan, food coloring and sugar cookie dough. And don’t forget the toothpicks!

Courtesy MyRecipes.com

One lick of this creamy ice cream and your taste buds will do a double take — the cones are stuffed with instant mashed potatoes blended with cream cheese and scallions for a savory surprise.

Courtesy Pinterest via partypinching.com

You won’t find any ground round in this faux shepherd’s pie, a sugary delight of Cocoa Krispies Treat beef and taffy carrots and peas. The mashed potato topping is made with melted marshmallows and butter and browned under the broiler.

Courtesy Pinterest via RachaelRayMag.com

Grab a slice of this cheesy pizza and you’ll get the shock of your life — it’s actually a tart made with fresh strawberries, mascarpone and mint.

Courtesy Pinterest via Triedandtruefavoriterecipes.blogspot.com

When is spaghetti not really spaghetti? When it’s frosting pushed through a pastry bag to form strands (you could also use a zip-top plastic bag), then it’s covered with fresh strawberry sauce subbing for marinara. And the meatballs? They’re chocolate no-bake cookies rolled into mounds. Mangia!

Courtesy Pinterest via CakeCentral.com

This will crack you up: The broken eggshells are made from white chocolate and the yolks from lemon pudding.

Courtesy Pinterest via Food.com

No need to worry about carbs when you toss back a few of these French fries since they’re made with apples, cinnamon and sugar and dipped into strawberry jam. Bonus points for using a crinkle cutter.

Courtesy Pinterest via TasteBook.com

These carrot cupcakes topped with cream cheese-nut frosting are actually mini meatloaves with mashed potatoes sprinkled with chopped bacon. We’ll take a dozen!

Courtesy Pinterest via Woman’s Day

You’ll have sweet memories of TV dinners after a few bites of this meal, where the chicken is really cake rolled in corn flakes and the mashed potatoes is made from an iced cupcake. The clever baker subbed caramel sauce for the gravy and cubed bits of colored candies for the veggies. Even the table is edible—it’s a two-layer vanilla cake covered with frosting and fondant.

Courtesy Pinterest Via Schax Yusuf

Who would cover a luscious chocolate cake with asparagus? No one, which is why these spears and tips are made of green fondant.

Courtesy Pinterest via PartyPinching.com

A classic appetizer takes a crunchy turn when the shrimp are made from Rice Krispies Treats and wrapped in pink fondant. Strawberry preserves masquerade as tomato-based cocktail sauce that’s garnished with a candy lemon slice and chive fondant garnish.

Courtesy Pinterest via acasarella.net

Don’t try munching on this popcorn at the movies unless you’re prepared to wipe up crumbs: The bucket is a yellow cupcake covered with a paper wrapper. The just-popped kernels? Mini marshmallows with a crisscross design and yellow food coloring “butter.”

Courtesy Pinterest via Parents.com

Cheese and crackers, anyone? Hope you like yours made with white and orange fruit chews (microwaved to get soft enough to mold) and sandwich cookies.

Courtesy Pinterest via theidearoom.net

No need to wait for dessert to eat this strawberry pie — it’s really meat loaf (with barbecue sauce, molasses and unsweetened cocoa powder) topped with mashed potatoes colored pink by beets.

Courtesy Pinterest via Yummly

Look closely at the bread on this grilled cheese sandwich — it’s really sliced pound cake. The melted cheese doesn’t have an ounce of dairy but it’s got plenty of sugar since it’s really buttercream frosting with a few drops of yellow food coloring.

—Nancy Mattia

FILED UNDER: Baking , Dessert , Food

Share this story:

Your reaction:

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

Showing 11 comments

DaisyMoon on

#7…it’s yolks, not yokes…dummy

Trish on

LOL! These are so cool. I love it, thank you!

Pickles on

Buttercream frosting does, indeed, have dairy. It’s made with butter and milk! Oh, and apples do have quite a few carbs, as well as the strawberry jam you dip them in. But I’d still eat them 😉

JackP on

The slideshow is not working.

IT guy: I’m on latest Chrome on Windows 7. Please talk to your bosses about how slideshows for lists are terrible for users.

Fiona on

I agree with Jack!

Maggie on

Just tried this with Safari and Chrome… Slideshow is not working. Is that the April Fools joke??

Sarah Levigne on

The Asparagus Cake is from Sweetapolita.com. I’m surprised you can get away with just crediting “Pinterest?”

Katie Anderson on

You can have a lot of fun when it comes to the food for small event parties. I really like the idea of making the food memorable, and working with a caterer can ensure that the food is the center point of you event. The caterers have so much experience in this kind of thing that they will be able to give you ideas on what would work best for your party. http://www.cincinnaticatering.com/cc/cater_private_party.php

read what he said on

She gets an F for fail, not a C- as she indicates. I don’t think she took the challenge seriously because she doesn’t have to. So many people trying to feed their families on very little and she makes a joke of it by not committing to the challenge. I was a fan til now. Wake up and smell the coffee (I know that you can afford coffee). Don’t half-ass something because it is hard, just shows what kind of character you have – not much!


Sustain the spectacular work !! Lovin’ it!

Jean Dallaire on

hacker un compte facebook


Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters