Alex Guarnaschelli: How I Almost Turned Down Chopped — And Why I’m Glad I Didn’t

06/04/2014 at 05:02 PM ET

Alex Guarnaschelli
Courtesy Alex Guarnaschelli

Alex Guarnaschelli is an Iron Chef, Food Network celebrity chef and the executive chef at New York City’s Butter restaurants. Read her PEOPLE.com blog every Tuesday to get her professional cooking tips, family-favorite recipes and personal stories of working in front of the camera and behind the kitchen doors. Follow her on Twitter at @guarnaschelli.

There are times when you end up in a place by complete accident. And times when that ends up becoming the most wonderful thing.

I’ll always remember the afternoon I got a call from a colleague asking me if I would please become part of a pilot for a Food Network show called Chopped. He described the format as competition-based with lots of teaching and learning about varied baskets of ingredients from cultures all around the world. “Sounds great to me,” I responded politely, “but I am busy that day.”

Why did I decline? I wonder, as I look back. I think I worried the show would be mean-spirited. I worried about failure. I worried about falling in love with the process only to have the show go away.

A month or two later, I received a copy of the pilot episode from the Food Network offices. “Watch how great this is,” the note in the envelope read. And it was. And that was all it took to convince me.

Alex Guarnaschelli
Courtesy Alex Guarnaschelli

And here I am in L.A., six whole years later, to participate on a panel to discuss the show. I am bowled away by the statues and sculptures outside the building where the panel will be held. My favorite is the one of Lucille Ball, certainly a hero of mine. Funny. Bold, unafraid. When I flip my TV to the occasional episode of I Love Lucy, I laugh still, and marvel that a television show can endure for so long. The two couples on the show seemed so close, even through the bickering and misunderstandings. I feel a similar closeness between us cast members on Chopped.

Scott Conant, a fellow judge, and I have known each other for more than 15 years and we cannot stop laughing when we hang out. He makes fun of me for being Italian and not making Italian food in my restaurant. I make fun of him for not being Italian and making Italian food in his restaurants. He is really someone I can trust and be myself with.

Alex Guarnaschelli
Courtesy Alex Guarnaschelli

The same is true of Ted Allen, the host. Have you ever known someone who can memorize a page of a script in 3 minutes flat and then ad lib the rest of the time? He is also very passionate about the contestants and the show.

Amanda Freitag, another fellow judge, has a great memory of many episodes and contestants. She also keeps the boat on course. I will be lost in someone’s story or stuck on some creative touch on a dish and she will look at me and say something super simple like, “The eggs were really overcooked and inconsistent.” I’ll agree, smiling and realizing that had she not reminded me of the critical fundamentals, I’d be lost at sea.

And then there’s Marc Murphy. The voice of reason at the toughest moments, he once spent an hour (successfully) explaining to me why my vote for one contestant was actually misguided.

Truth is, we can’t all help picking a favorite when we step on the set. The problem is that you never know what is going to happen between the contents of those baskets being unveiled and that clock expiring. It’s like gambling, and the skill set of the cook is never a sure bet. We discuss that on this panel in great detail.

We step outside into the cool night air of Los Angeles and proceed to the reception area where various people have gathered to snap a picture with Ted Allen. “Remember the one episode where there was nothing but raw chicken?’ one person asks.

“When they put Durian in the basket, I just don’t know how contestants deal with something like that with so little time!” another exclaims.

“My daughter and I buy the ingredients from various baskets and cook with them at home to familiarize ourselves with new ingredients,” one woman confides.

“My 8-year-old granddaughter told me I was chopped the other day for overcooking her eggs,” chuckles a grandfather from the back of the crowd.

As I watch reactions and stories come from the crowd, I realize that Chopped puts everyone on common ground. Everyone learns something. Everyone empathizes with mistakes made or shouts at the TV when someone takes an unfortunate path with a basket. In some way, in some form, we have all been chopped…

Share this story:

Your reaction:

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

Showing 13 comments

Lynelle Wagner on

I have watched Chopped since the first episode! I love all the judges but Alex is my favorite. She helps me to understand *why* certain flavors do or do not work together. I admire how brave those judges have to be to put some of those dishes in their mouths!

MsDaisy on

I love how Alex always disagrees with Geoffrey Zakarian. No matter what he says, she goes the opposite direction. It’s awesome!

Ally on

I love Alex’s attitude. And her recipes never fail!

luv on

I love Chopped!

Stefanie on

Excellent show! Its always fun to watch. (and i REALLY love when Aaron is on! ;) )

chopped no more on

She may be good on camera, but she is one of the meanest people i’ve ever worked with.

jjgg744 on

She might want to give Jenny Craig a try.

Lucy on

I ran into Chef Alex shopping in LA and graciously told her what a fan I am of the show. OMG, it was if I was a stalkerazzi invading her privacy! Living in LA you see celebrities all the time and I didn’t really think of her as a celebrity. Alex, if you didn’t want the attention, then you should have stayed in the kitchen!

George Bush on

Her butt is enormous, it has gotten smaller since her 1st Iron chef run though, it was like 4 feet wide back then.

Seminole Girl on

Watching Chopped has changed the way I cook most nights. They didn’t mention Geoffrey Z. I love him as a judge.

whatever on

I work in the building with the Food Network in the Chelsea Market and this woman has a foul little mouth on her lol. She was buying food in the “fruit exchange” and I got quite an ear full – made me like her b/c she always seems so tired and almost bored.

Mary on

Chopped is my favorite show and Chef Alex is one of my favorite judges! I love how she’s so tough on the outside and pure marshmallow on the inside. Besides, I’ve got to love anyone who can sous-chef for Geoffrey Zacarian and have him saying “yes, Chef” to HER.

Tommie on

I used to watch chopped, but the judges are so smug and mean to the people. Alex looks like she is eating garbage when she tries a dish. Not much love for Food Network anymore.

advertisement

From Our Partners

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 475 other followers

Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters