Which American Idol Judge Would Send Peeps Milk to Hollywood?

03/11/2015 at 12:57 PM ET

“It’s going to Hollywood!”

American Idol judge Harry Connick Jr. wasn’t praising the vocal range of an up-and-coming singer, but rather the deliciousness of a new line of Peeps-flavored milk. Connick, joined by fellow judges Jennifer Lopez and Keith Urban, taste-tested the new candy-inspired milks — don’t worry, they’re reduced-fat! — on Jimmy Kimmel Live! Tuesday night.

While Lopez looked mildly revolted, Urban, Connick and Jimmy Kimmel sipped the Easter milks — which comes in eggnog, marshmallow and chocolate marshmallow flavors — as if they were fine wine.

“That’s really good,” said Urban, who sampled the eggnog flavor.

Lopez, who tried the marshmallow, didn’t think much of the drink, which she described as “milky sugar” before giving her barely sipped glass back to Kimmel.

“It’s just pure sugar. It’s like that,” Kimmel observed, drinking a cocktail he whipped up of all three milks together. “It’s like the bottom of the cereal bowl without having to eat cereal.”

Like Lopez, we’re not sure how we feel about Peeps Milk, but we do know that Kimmel’s idea to spike it with rum could take the novelty beverage to the next level.

—Maria Yagoda

Share this story:

Your reaction:

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

Showing 0 comments

Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters