Find Out What Food the Cast of OITNB Would Go to Jail For

06/15/2015 at 05:42 PM ET

Taryn Manning
Netflix; Getty

The ladies of Litchfield have to deal with some very unpleasant meals while locked up (like Piper’s tampon sandwich from season 1), but that doesn’t mean the Orange Is the New Black actresses don’t have serious palates in their real lives.

The food website Delish.com caught up with the cast to beg the question: What food would you go to prison for? And their answers are both random and awesome.

While Taryn Manning‘s character Pennsatucky praises Jesus, Manning worships Mexican and pizza.

“In California we have a place called Del Taco; otherwise Taco Bell is my weakness. I can’t get enough mild sauce in the yellow packet,” she said, adding her other true love is “margherita pizza that is extra crispy, and super thin.”

The Netflix show’s Assistant to the Warden Alysia Reiner revealed she is all about the sweets.

When she’s not having some kind of chocolate “every day,” Reiner says she’s “dipping marshmallows in peanut butter. I ask my husband to hide the peanut butter so I don’t go crazy.”

Some of our other favorite food answers include Jackie Cruz (Flaca) admitting she drinks leftover salad dressing, Laura Gomez (Blanca) saying she’d “fight with someone for a good French onion soup,” and the series’ resident mute Annie Golden (Norma) not having much of a response at all.

“I’m not really a foodie. I’m pretty bland,” says Golden but admitting: “If I go to a restaurant, I look for the appetizers and if they have a shrimp cocktail, I’m good to go. When they don’t, I kind of go, ‘Really? Really?’ ”

Orange Is the New Black season 3 is streaming now on Netflix.

—Ana Calderone, @anacalderone

Share this story:

Your reaction:

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

Showing 3 comments

Hatethisloser on

What about Red? Out of all people I’m shocked Kate wasn’t in this article!

DD on

SORRY, BUT THAT CRUST DOES NOT LOOK RIGHT AT ALL. DO THESE PHOTOGRAPHERS, OR WHOMEVER IS IN CHARGE OF PUTTING THESE THINGS TOGETHER, THINK WE ARE TOTAL IDIOTS AND CAN’T SEE FOR OURSELVES THAT THAT PIZZA IS NOT RIGHT AND DOES NOT LOOK RIGHT, LIKE IT’S SUPPOSED TO LOOK? MOREOVER, WHERE THE HELL IS A PROFESSIONAL RESTAURANT/PIZZA EATERY QUALITY RECIPE AT, LIKE THE RECIPES THEY USE IN PIZZA PLACES AND RESTAURANTS?? THAT IS WHAT WE REALLY WANT. WE WANT THE EXACT SAME RECIPE, ALL THE EXACT SAME INGREDIENTS, BRANDS, AND ALL THE SECRET INSIDE INFO THAT THESE PIZZA PLACES USE, SO WE CAN RECREATE THEM IN OUR OWN HOME. IT THESE PLACES WOULD LOWER THEIR PRICES AND WOULDN’T CHARGE US AN ARM AND A LEG, WE WOULD PATRONIZED THEIR ESTABLISHMENTS INSTEAD, BUT THEY ARE FAR TOO GREEDY.

Jay on

@DD, the pizza crust looks exactly the way it should for a margherita pizza that is super thin/extra crispy…and for crying out loud, turn OFF your cap lock! SMH.

Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters