EXCLUSIVE: American Pie’s Chris Klein Served Three Beautiful Cakes at His Wedding — See the Sweet Photos

08/21/2015 at 11:55 AM ET

Chris Klein Wedding Cake
Meg Smith

Chris Klein made sure there was a very sweet ending to his picturesque wedding on Aug. 9 in Montana.

The American Pie actor, 36, and his bride, travel agent Laina Rose Thyfault, 30, treated their 115 guests to an elaborate dessert table with mini crème brûlée cupcakes and three — yes, three! — beautiful wedding cakes.

“We wanted to use local outfitters to celebrate Montana and all the things the folks are doing there,” Klein tells PEOPLE.

RELATED: See Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux’s Wedding Cake: The Puppet Theme Explained!

So the couple turned to Bozeman-based company Whipped, a bakery known for their unique flavors, to create their dream desserts.

“It was a really fun cake tasting,” says Whipped owner Jasmine Snyder. “You could feel their excitement mounting over the flavors.”

Meg Smith

The couple decided on three wedding cakes. The first one was a two-tiered “naked” (or unfrosted) cake with a coconut base and an almond-flavored top layered with strawberry buttercream and fresh strawberries.

RELATED: All About Little People, Big World Star Zach Roloff’s Unique Poppyseed Raspberry Wedding Cake

For the second cake, Klein and Thyfault choose a crepe cake: a stack of paper-thin crepes layered with pastry cream, topped with fresh figs and raspberries, and drizzled with honey.

Chris Klein Wedding Cake
Meg Smith

And for the third confection, the couple chose a pecan pie cake, inspired by the classic southern dessert.

“Chris had mentioned loving pecan pie,” says Snyder. “I’ve had success translating pie flavors into cake so I made a pecan cake filling and then baked pie crust, pureed the pie crust, and whipped it into the butter cream frosting.”

Chris Klein Wedding Cake
Meg Smith

The result was a sweet success for the couple and their guests.

RELATED: See Our Favorite Celebrity Wedding Cakes

“I was really happy with how everything turned out,” says Snyder. “And they were a joy to work with.”

For more exclusive details on Chris Klein’s wedding, pick up this week’s issue of PEOPLE, on stands now.

—Mia McNiece

Share this story:

Your reaction:

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

Showing 3 comments

Sadie on

The first two sound delicious and yummy!

Easyup on

OMG all three sound amazing! I’ll take a slice of each, please.

KellyGreen on

..and now I want cake!!

Looks yummy 🙂 Congrats!

Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters