Can Jimmy Fallon Make a Better Grilled Cheese Than Mario Batali? Watch the Face-Off — and Get the Recipes

01/20/2016 at 11:18 AM ET

Grilled
The Tonight Show

Jimmy Fallon and Mario Batali‘s Tonight Show grilled cheese face-off got heated.

On Tuesday night’s episode, Fallon invited the celebrity chef on the show to whip up his signature grilled cheese, and the late night host challenged him by making one himself. After cooking the sandwiches, Questlove conducted a very professional blind taste test to choose the victor.

While Batali used the fancy, higher-end ingredients you’d expect from a renowned chef (truffle honey, artisanal sourdough bread), Fallon appealed to America’s populist sensibility with a Wonder Bread-American cheese creation (and a little maple butter to jazz it up).

RELATED: Liv Tyler and Mario Batali Share Grilled Cheese at N.Y.C. Diner

The trash-talking started the moment the face-off began, of course.

“Your cheese is already melting because it has an artificially low temperature because it’s not made of milk,” Batali said to Fallon. “Don’t you find that to be a problem, sir?”

After tasting both sandwiches, Questlove had a winner: Fallon’s. And we don’t necessarily blame him. No one, not even Batali, can compete with maple butter.

Here is our interpretation of the the two grilled cheese recipes  make them for yourself and see which you like best.

Mario Batali’s Truffled Grilled Cheese:
Sliced sourdough bread
Sliced ontina cheese
Sliced Graviera cheese
Black truffle honey

In a skillet, heat a couple tbsp. of butter over medium heat. Drizzle one slice of the bread with the honey and pile it high with each type of cheese. Top with another slice of bread and cook in the skillet until browned on each side and cheese is melted.

RELATED: This Ramen Bacon Grilled Cheese Is Your New Spirit Animal

Jimmy Fallon’s Maple Butter Grilled Cheese:
Sliced Wonderbread (or any other similarly plain white bread)
Sliced American cheese
Crumbled bacon
Maple syrup
Softened butter

Heat a panini press to medium. On one slice of bread, add cheese, bacon bits, a drizzle of maple syrup, and more cheese. In a small bowl, mix butter and another drizzle of syrup. Spread maple butter on the outside of each bread slice. Place in panini press and cook until browned and cheese is melted.

(We’re still partial to the waffle grilled cheeses that Elmo made with Fallon in August.)

—Maria Yagoda, @mariayagoda

Share this story:

Your reaction:

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

Showing 3 comments

trish on

Get the recipes? It’s grilled cheese!!

lin on

Jimmy’s hand really looks gross at times when the camera catches it just right. It looks like he still has no feelings in it.

sandyra on

Look, IF you are going to make a grilled cheese sandwich it won’t be worth a damn if it doesn’t have a fresh, ripe tomato between the slices.

From Our Partners

Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters